McCarthy, Cormac (1992) ‘All the Pretty Horses’, US signed and inscribed uncorrected proof with rock solid provenance

Provenance: From the Dr Philip Murray collection. Medical Doctor Philip Murray (1940-2019) from Sligo, Ireland was an avid reader of literary fiction and became a passionate collector of first edition books. He only collected what he also enjoyed reading. In 2011 he published his memoirs titled ‘Adventures of a Book Collector’ [Currach Press] where he recalls his collecting career spanning over four decades. In his memoirs he dedicates four pages to Cormac McCarthy (pp 120-24) and one photographic plate which depicts Murray and McCarthy arm in arm in Sligo in 2004. Murray relates that he wrote to Cormac in 1990 before McCarthy hit fame with his Border trilogy. McCarthy agreed to sign and return his books and over the years they maintained correspondence with the highlight being McCarthy’s visit in Sligo in 2004. Murray embarked on a complete author collection of McCarthy. In the summer of 2016 his vast collection of over 2,000 books was sold in Dublin at auction fetching over EUR 275,000. However, it speaks volumes that Murray could not bring himself to part with his McCarthy collection back in 2016 but kept it until he died. Too strong his love for the work of the author.

Cormac McCarthy is a very private author who has granted just a handful of interviews to journalists. His principle is that it is better to write than to talk about writing. As a result genuine signed books are few and far between and provenance is key. We recommend that ‘flat signed’ copies should be avoided by the collector as signed material is rare and many forgers cannot resist the temptation of ‘enhancing a book’s monetary value’. Whilst a ‘flat signed’ copy might be genuine, in our opinion the risk of acquiring a forgery is too great.

‘All the Pretty Horses’ is McCarthy’s sixth novel and the first in his ‘Border Trilogy’. The book bacame McCarthy’s breaktrhough work and earned him the U.S. National Book Award and the National Book Critics Circle Award. Filmed in 2000 starring Matt Damon and Penelope Cruz. We cannot trace a single genuinely signed and inscribed uncorrected proof sold in the past.